| 2012 | Emily Kuo | MIT |
| 2011 | Lisa Wojnar | Babson |
| Jackie Moscardelli | Springfield |
| 2010 | Lauren Hernley | MIT |
| 2009 | Lauren Hernley | MIT |
| 2008 | Lauren Peltier | Springfield |
| 2007 | Erin Davis | Wheaton |
| 2006 | Amy Ludlum | MIT |
| 2005 | Lauren Konopka | Wheaton |
| 2004 | Beth Caromile | Wheaton |
| 2003 | Erin Duffy | Wheaton |
| 2002 | Tracy Prihoda | Wheaton |
| 2001 | Tracy Prihoda | Wheaton |
| 2000 | Alison Bimba | Wheaton |
| 1999 | Sarah Hilgenberg | Wellesley |
| 1998 | Molly Hellerman | Wellesley |
| 1997 | Katie Knudsen Christina Mirrione | Wellesley Wheaton |
| 1996 | Katie Knudsen | Wellesley |
| 1995 | Sarah Gianfriddo | Clark |
| 1994 | Becky Hill | MIT |
| 1993 | Julie Tienken | Babson |
| 1992 | Julie Tienken | Babson |
| 1991 | Julie Tienken | Babson |
| 1990 | Eleanor Ewald | Mount Holyoke |
| 1989 | Stephanie Cutting | Mount Holyoke |
| 1988 | Pam Vaughan | Brandeis |
| 1987 | Betsy Herrmann | Smith |
