| 2012 | Julia Cipriano | Wheaton |
| 2011 | Jessica DiPhilippo | Babson |
| 2010 | Megan Forti | WPI |
| 2009 | Cassey Muse | Wheaton |
| 2008 | Yuko Takahashi | Mount Holyoke |
| 2007 | Melida Alvarez | Wheaton |
| 2006 | Liz Theurer | MIT |
| 2005 | Lauren Peltier | Springfield |
| 2004 | Lauren Konopka | Wheaton |
| 2003 | Jordan Pouliot | Wheaton |
| 2002 | Catherine Peo | Smith |
| 2001 | Erin Brennan | Wheaton |
| 2000 | Elizabeth Senecal | Wellesley |
| 1999 | Alison Bimba | Wheaton |
| 1998 | Katie Brothers | Clark |
| 1997 | Amanda Edelhart | Smith |
| 1996 | Sarah Hilgenberg | Wellesley |
| 1995 | Christina Mirrione | Wheaton |
| 1994 | Eileen Connolly | Babson |
| 1993 | Andrea Illes | Brandeis |
| 1992 | Janice Cutler | Babson |
| 1991 | Helen Karalis | Babson |
