| 2012 | Mary Donahue | Babson |
| 2011 | Sydney Carfagno | Wellesley |
| 2010 | Kelsey DePorto | Coast Guard |
| 2009 | Isabel Custodio | Wellesley |
| 2008 | Cecily
Joujon-Roche Kim Giaquinto |
MIT Springfield |
| 2007 | Bethany Stosz | Springfield |
| 2006 | Alex Day | MIT |
| 2005 | Nicole Gurr | Coast Guard |
| 2004 | Corrine McCormack | Coast Guard |
| 2003 | Leah Hettrick | Springfield |
| 2002 | Austin Zimmerman | MIT |
| 2001 | Danielle Ling | Wellesley |
| 2000 | Jennifer Pollakusky | Wellesley |
| 1999 | Ali Mostue | Wellesley |
| 1998 | Rachel Zimet | WPI |
| 1997 | Bonnie Campbell | Wheaton |
| 1996 | Allison Schnitzer | Wellesley |
| 1995 | Katie Houser | Wellesley |
| 1994 | Carolyn Holt | Smith |
| 1993 | Laura Quintana | Smith |
| 1992 | Kamilah Alexander | MIT |
| 1991 | Anna Diaz | Wellesley |
